Mayor Pete’s “Carbon Tax and Dividend” Will Raise Taxes on Social Security Recipients

Share on Facebook
Tweet this Story
Pin this Image

Posted by Adam Sabes on Friday, December 20th, 2019, 12:19 AM PERMALINK

Pete Buttigieg repeated his call for a “carbon tax and dividend” at the Democratic debate in Los Angeles on Thursday night during the PBS/Politico Democratic debate.

And it’s why I insist we act with a carbon tax and dividend with massive increases in renewable research on renewable energy storage and carbon storage,” Buttigieg said.

Buttigieg's carbon tax plan is a large, continually ratcheting national energy tax, which would allows congress to raise taxes automatically each year without having to vote. It would require a large bureaucracy to implement and run.

Most devastating for voters, however, is that it will impose severe tax increases on Social Security recipients.

Because the Buttigieg carbon tax would significantly increase household costs -- cooling and heating, transportation, groceries, etc. -- the bill directs the federal government to send payments to households in an attempt to compensate for the increased cost burden.

But these payments, called "dividends" by Buttigieg -- are subject to federal income tax. The tax will not only siphon money from households to be sent to Washington -- it will also impact Social Security benefits.

report published by the pro-carbon tax Citizens' Climate Lobby acknowledges the following:

"Taxability of Dividends raises three separate issues: (i) additional complexity for taxpayers; (ii) the equity of the disparate effective marginal tax rates on taxable Dividends for various residents; and (iii) the method or methods by which those taxes would be paid."

Regarding Social Security recipients, the report states:

"Over the income-related phase-in range for the taxation of social security benefits, each additional $1.00 of non-social security income causes an additional $0.50 or $0.85 of social security benefits to become taxable. In most situations, the ordinary income tax rate in the phase-in range is 10 percent; however, at some income levels, the rate is 12 percent. Thus, $1.00 of non-social security income -- including income from the Dividend -- will be taxed at effective marginal rates of 15 percent, 18 percent, or 22.2 percent."

The report gives an example of how the tax would hit a typical couple over age 65 with an income of $38,000 and a Social Security benefit of $12,000:

"Based on that income, the tax rate schedule shows that their marginal tax rate would be 10 percent. However, the addition of $1,584 of taxable Dividends from the Carbon Fee causes more of their social security benefits to become taxable, and their marginal tax rate due to the Dividends is 20.12 percent, so that after paying their income tax, the couple is left with only 79.88 percent of their gross Dividend."

Citizens' Climate Lobby was caught on tape admitting carbon tax cost and complexity is "something that we at CCL can tend to soft-pedal."

It's no wonder 75 conservative groups wrote a letter to congress stating: "We oppose any carbon tax."

See more:

Booker Praises Opportunity Zones While Planning to Repeal TCJA Which Created Them

Buttigieg Praises Opportunity Zones, Vows to Eliminate TCJA Which Created the Zones in the First Place

Sanders: “Of Course” Medicare for All Will Cost You Something

Despite Steep Tax Hikes, Biden’s Numbers Don’t Add Up

Biden: Capital Gains Tax Rate “Could Go Higher” Than 40%

Biden on Medicare for All: “You’re Going to Have to Raise Taxes on the Middle Class”

Sanders Senior Adviser: “Yes, We Will Repeal the Trump Tax Scam”

Bloomberg Endorsed a Carbon Tax

Biden to Sanders and Warren: “Let’s Get Realistic” on Trillion Dollar Spending Plans

Booker: I Would Raise the Capital Gains Tax Rate

List of Buttigieg Tax Hike Proposals

2020 Dems: Warren's Medicare for All Will Raise Middle Class Taxes

Fact Check: Mark Zandi Misleads Americans, Claims Warren’s Healthcare Plan Will Not Raise Middle Class Taxes

Warren: Medicare for All Covers Illegal Immigrants

Elizabeth Warren Contradicts Herself on Taxes, Again

Biden: Imagine if I Told Elizabeth Warren ‘You Should Be In a Socialist Primary’

CNN Catches Warren in a Tax Lie

Bernie Sanders: Warren’s Medicare for All Plan Would Have “Very Negative Impact” on Jobs and Wages

Warren Claims Americans Making Less Than One Billion Dollars Will “Not Pay a Penny More” in Taxes Under Her Medicare for All Plan

Warren’s “Medicare for All” Repeals Trump Tax Cuts

Biden: Warren is "Making it Up" on How She'll Pay for Medicare For All

Biden: “It’s Impossible to pay for Medicare for All without middle class tax increases”

Biden Slams Medicare for All: “It’s Totally Unrealistic and Can’t be Done”

Warren: Two Million Lost Jobs from Medicare for All “Part of the Cost Issue”

Video Showing Every Time Elizabeth Warren Has Dodged the Middle Class Tax Question

Out of touch Biden calls Trump’s $2,000 middle class tax cut “negligible”

Biden Calls for 28% Corporate Tax Rate

Biden: “Every Single Solitary Person” Will Pay 40% Capital Gains Tax

Warren Dodges the Middle Class Tax Question Again

Buttigieg Says He Will Raise Corporate Tax Rate to 35%

Watch: CNN Analyst Gets Visibly Irritated as Warren Dodges Tax Hike Question

Andrew Yang to Elizabeth Warren: Wealth Tax Would Have “Massive Implementation Problems”

Biden on Warren Dodging Middle Class Tax Question: “This is Ridiculous. Absolutely Ridiculous.”

Buttigieg Grills Warren for Dodging the Middle Class Tax Question

Biden: I Will Raise the Capital Gains Tax to 39.5%

Elizabeth Warren Can’t Stop Dodging the Middle Class Tax Question

VIDEO: 17 Times Elizabeth Warren Has Dodged the Middle Class Tax Question

VIDEO: Warren Keeps Dodging the Middle Class Tax Question

Biden: “I’m Gonna Double the Capital Gains Rate to 40%”

Tax Hike Bernie Says He’ll Tax All Income Over $29K 

Video: Warren Dodges Middle Class Tax Question Again

Biden Calls for Full Repeal of Trump Tax Cuts

Biden Attacks Warren: "She's Going to Raise People's Taxes”

Video: Media Fed Up with Elizabeth Warren Tax Dodge

Biden: End "Trump's Tax Cut for The Top Tenth of One Percent"

Booker: “My plan would reverse those toxic Trump tax cuts”

Stephen Colbert Calls Out Warren for Dodging Middle Class Tax Question

Video: Warren Dodges MSNBC’s Middle Class Tax Questions

Elizabeth Warren is Still Dodging the Middle Class Tax Question

Video: 2020 Democrats Promise Higher Taxes

Biden Caught Lying about GOP Tax Cuts

Bill De Blasio: “As President, I Would Issue a Robot Tax”

Biden Endorses Carbon Tax

Kamala Harris Calls for Ban on Plastic Straws

Elizabeth Warren's Climate Plan Calls For "Reversing" GOP Tax Cuts

Sanders: We’re Going to “Absolutely” Raise the Corporate Tax Rate

Elizabeth Warren on Corporate Tax Cuts: “I really want to see them rolled back.”

Bill de Blasio Calls for Corporate Tax Rate Hike

Amy Klobuchar: Raise the Corporate Tax Rate to 25%

Biden on capital gains tax: “We should raise the tax back to 39.6 percent”

Kamala Harris Threatens to Repeal GOP Tax Cuts 3 Times in August

Joe Biden: “I’m going to eliminate most all” of GOP Tax Cuts

Cory Booker Calls for Repeal of "Toxic" GOP Tax Cuts

Marianne Williamson Joins Dems Calling for TCJA Repeal

Kamala Admits Her Plan Would End Employer Insurance

“Medicare for All” is a Middle Class Tax Increase, Say Dems

Elizabeth Warren Can’t Dodge the Middle Class Tax Question Forever

Dem Socialized Healthcare Plan Will Lead to Middle Class Tax Hikes

Elizabeth Warren "Wealth Tax" was described by the WaPo editorial board as having "a certain authoritarian odor"

Supposed “Moderate” Democrat John Delaney Wants to Impose Carbon Tax on the American People

Klobuchar Suggests Capital Gains Tax Hike and “Doing Something” About TCJA

VIDEO: 2020 Democrats Will Raise Your Taxes

Kamala Harris Campaign Headquarters Located in Opportunity Zone Created by GOP Tax Cuts

Julian Castro: “We’re going to have to raise taxes.”

Biden and Harris: Raise the Corporate Tax Rate

Biden tweet: Ignore the fact I’ve already called for middle class tax hikes

Kamala Harris: “I Will Reverse” Trump’s Tax Cuts

Kamala Harris Calls for Repeal of Tax Cuts Four Times in Three Minutes

Julian Castro Caught Lying about GOP Tax Cuts

NYT: Bidencare Will be Funded by “rolling back” GOP tax cuts

Kamala Harris: I Will Repeal “That Tax Bill”

Cory Booker: “I do support” Imposing Carbon Tax on Americans

Harris: “We are Going to Repeal That Tax Bill”

Biden: I Will Raise Corporate Tax Rate to 28%

Kamala Harris Continues to Lie about Tax Cuts

Jay Inslee: “Repeal the Trump Tax Cuts”

Biden Running Ads to “Repeal Trump’s Tax Cuts.”

VIDEO: Ten Times Biden Threatened to Repeal Tax Cuts

Here’s what happens if Dems repeal tax cuts

VIDEO: 10 Times 2020 Democrats Have Threatened to Repeal TCJA

Kamala Harris: When I Enter Office "I Will Repeal" the TCJA

Biden: “First thing I would do as President is Eliminate the President’s Tax Cut.”

Bernie Sanders claims people would be “delighted to pay more in taxes”

Biden: Tax Cuts Will be “Gone” If I’m Elected

Kamala Harris: I Will Repeal Tax Cuts “on day one”

Biden again says capital gains tax is “Much too Low”

Biden: Capital gains tax “much too low”

VIDEO: Five Times Biden has Threatened to Repeal Tax Cuts

Biden: “First thing I’d do is repeal those Trump tax cuts.”

Joe Biden broke his middle class tax pledge

“Mayor Pete” Calls for Steep Tax Hike on Homes and Businesses

Kamala Harris Vows Repeal of Tax Cuts “on Day One”

Biden: “When I’m President, if God willing I am, we’re going to reverse those Trump tax cuts.”

×